While
Bob Segarini is a hero to pop obsessives thanks to his bright, rollicking work with
the Wackers and his superb solo album
Gotta Have Pop, his recordings with his early group
the Family Tree are a different and more sophisticated kettle of fish.
The Family Tree's sole LP, 1968's
Miss Butters, was a concept album at a time when that was still a very novel thing, and the LP boasted intelligent, beautifully crafted songs bolstered by polished, thoughtful production from
Rick Jarrard and imaginative arrangements by
George Tipton.
Miss Butters was recorded while
Jarrard and
Tipton were working on another ambitious exercise in chamber pop,
Harry Nilsson's
Aerial Ballet, and a few of the same session musicians play on both albums, while
Nilsson collaborated with
Segarini on one of the album's tunes, "Butters Lament." While it would be going a bit overboard to suggest
Miss Butters is a better album than
Aerial Ballet, in many respects time has been kinder to
the Family Tree's effort;
Nilsson's work, fine as it is, is sometimes hampered by an air of nostalgia for an era that he never saw, but
Segarini's songs evoke their time and place with a more potent and less self-conscious tone, and the tale of the sad life and times of an elderly school teacher remain poignant and effective without schmaltz. Suggesting a middle ground between
the Kinks'
The Village Green Preservation Society and the best sides of
the Left Banke,
Miss Butters is a lovely, overlooked triumph of '60s chamber pop, and it documents a facet of
Bob Segarini's talent that isn't evident on much of his later work.
–
Mark Deming, Rovi